Viper Club of America Discussion Forums
  Performance Modifications
  Better than Caldwell?!?
  

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Edit your Profile Register HERE!! Set Preferences FAQ's Search

ViperFriend: Email This Page to Someone!     Click to print this page next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Better than Caldwell?!?
treynor
Click for full size
Proud VCA Member

From:Redwood City, CA
Registered: Nov 2000

posted 05-08-2001 07:48 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


From various discussions on this board and with local Viper tech's, I had formed the assumption that Caldwell was first among equals when it came to Viper engine modifications -- they did the best work, and they charged some of the highest prices. In particular, I had heard that their head porting work was the reference standard by which all others were judged. You can thus imagine my surprise when I got the flow numbers for my soon-to-be-installed Hennessey heads and they were better than the Caldwell-ported flow numbers posted in the Viper board FAQ:

Valve Stock Caldwell Hennessey
Lift(") Intake Exhaust Intake Exhaust Intake Exhaust
0.10 61 54 61 59 62 54
0.20 118 115 125 116 122 127
0.30 167 155 178 170 179 179
0.40 203 180 214 204 228 200
0.50 229 185 247 210 261 209
0.60 242 187 270 214 274 214
0.70 n/a n/a n/a n/a 282 217

Suffice to say I'm very much looking forward to some dyno and dragstrip figures when these heads are installed in early June! In the meantime, thumbs up to Hennessey & team for a great porting job.

------------------
Cheers, Ben ('98M3'99RX300'00M5'01GP1200R'01RT/10AndNoGarageSpaceLeft!)


Click Here to See the Profile for treynor   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by treynor   Visit treynor's Homepage!        send a private message to treynor
Martin D
Click for full size

From:Dunwoody, GA USA
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-09-2001 09:15 AM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Ben,

That is not a surprise to me. I can tell you the Venom 650 heads I got from HMS were MACK DADDY!!! They were awesome. They were on the very ragged edge for performance. You will make huge power with those heads and the stock cam. I cant wait to see your RWHP numbers,

Regards,

------------------
Martin Drucker
98RT10
HMS Venom 650R


Click Here to See the Profile for Martin D   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by Martin D   Visit Martin D's Homepage!        send a private message to Martin D
Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder
SoCal VCA Member

From:Saratoga,CA
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-09-2001 06:39 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Better than Caldwell? Better at what? Better than Caldwell endurance Road Racing engines? I think NOT! But if you think the other tuners build better engine than Caldwell, I guess Chrysler/ORECA must have missed something? How many Vipers raced in the FIA series, ALMS, Speedvision series with the tuner who you think makes a better engine? How many races have they won? I hope you enjoy your high flow heads, but to slam Caldwell has ZERO basis. Their engines have won 3 Le Mans races, ALMS series, FIA series, over all winner at the Daytona 24 hour race in 2000. Why slam the proven best endurance Viper engine builder? Have you inquired with CDI to determine their flow options? CDI builds engines for specific racing applications, the heads are only a part of a system! Let me know when any of your tuners have an engine dyno to verify the best performance of a performance package. How do they know what works best? Bigger is always Better, GOOD LUCK!

------------------
Fred Kinder


Click Here to See the Profile for Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder           send a private message to Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder
Martin D
Click for full size

From:Dunwoody, GA USA
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-09-2001 09:21 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Fred,

I missed the slam on Caldwell. I also missed the statement that any tuner is better than Caldwell. I think Ben was merely stating a fact - that the HMS heads had better flow than he expected - and better than the posted imformation in regards to Caldwell. I doubt any one on this board thinks that anything Caldwell has done is less than spectacular. They have been put in the position of reference. Since they are the Standard, why not report that the HMS heads had good flow numbers. I for one applaud the information in the post. Good job Ben.

Regards,

------------------
Martin Drucker
98RT10
HMS Venom 650R


Click Here to See the Profile for Martin D   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by Martin D   Visit Martin D's Homepage!        send a private message to Martin D
getbit
Click for full size
Proud VCA Member

From:Lake Charles,LA. USA
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-09-2001 10:02 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Relax Fred. We all know Caldwell at least by accomplishments and reputation. Incredible people! I agree it was informative to see info in regards to the standard setting Caldwell equipment and others.

------------------
Jason B. Fontenot GETBIT!
2001 Saphire GTS with Silver Stripes
Shelby Cobra Replica(514ci-600hp)
2001 PT Cruiser Limited
2000 GMC Yukon XL 4X4


Click Here to See the Profile for getbit   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by getbit           send a private message to getbit
Chuck 98 RT/10
Click for full size

From:tampa, fl USA
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-09-2001 10:10 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


I thought of it as a compliment to Caldwell. Being held as the "first among equals" is a compliment. It's like people bragging about beating a Viper.

------------------
Chuck 98 RT/10


Click Here to See the Profile for Chuck 98 RT/10   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by Chuck 98 RT/10   Visit Chuck 98 RT/10's Homepage!        send a private message to Chuck 98 RT/10
99t1
Click for full size
NY/CT VCA Member

From:Pound Ridge, NY, USA
Registered: Dec 2000

posted 05-09-2001 10:32 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Fred is right...endurance is the key. Any bubba can dope up a motor for a short fast run. Can't win unless you finish. CDI has and will continue to bring Vipers to the podium.

------------------


Click Here to See the Profile for 99t1   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by 99t1           send a private message to 99t1
HouseofSpeed

From:Houston, TX
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-09-2001 11:50 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


FRED....I thought we had this discussion awhile back....you stay out of the engine business and we will all be better for it. Do you think Caldwell is the originator of the part(s)???? Hell, they get their castings from Buddy Bar just like DC does....and they buy their rocker arms from T&D just like DC does....and we can build a motor as good, if not better, than Caldwell.

Not to toot our collective horns, but the engine building experience at HMS is WAY DEEP. The current players have been responsible for everything from ASA motors to Pro Stock and Stock Eliminator to Silver Crown. Caldwell was in the right place at the right time, Ed Pink could have done the same work...as could Wegner, Chapman, et al. If you don't recognize those names....I'll give you a clue....THEY DON"T WORK FOR CDI AND THEY MAKE CARS GO FAST FOR EXTENDED PERIODS OF TIME. We at HMS can do the same thing....chances are you could come closer to affording one of our setups than you could a similar package at Caldwell.

EASE UP ON THE CALDWELL PROTEIN SHAKES...they are distorting reality for you Fred.

------------------
Kyle Kent
House of Speed
"Make power..not excuses"
[IMG]http://jwgross.home.texas.net/halologo1.jpg[/IMG]


Click Here to See the Profile for HouseofSpeed   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by HouseofSpeed   Visit HouseofSpeed's Homepage!        send a private message to HouseofSpeed
Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder
SoCal VCA Member

From:Saratoga,CA
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-10-2001 01:12 AM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Kyle, I like your emotion! Do not worry I am not after your job! Nor do I want to be a tuner! Congrats on getting a lot of good press for your big motors and fast Vipers. My opinion only, if I want a rock solid Viper engine I would consider Caldwell. They have a proven record. When someone else can produce the same winning results as CDI, then I will be glad to congratulate them for a job well done.

There are 4 Vipers entered at Le Mans, as well as many other cars. Caldwell engines are in at least 1 Viper (I think the other 3 Vipers are also powered by CDI engines) and 3 LMP cars.

Any other Viper tuners powering Le Mans rides?

I do like value for my $$$ and should I be fortunate to have the spare cash I would be happy to spend it with CDI, EMI, Dan Cragin, all relatively close to home and all with happy customers.

Martin, The topic is "Better than Caldwell"

Caldwell does not post on this board. So when someone comments "Better than Caldwell" I want to make sure the owners who do not know all the tuner's, at least know who is on first!


------------------
Fred Kinder


Click Here to See the Profile for Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder           send a private message to Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder
David Jenkins
Click for full size

From:South Orange County, CA.USA
Registered: Nov 2000

posted 05-10-2001 12:14 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Ben, are you building an endurance engine for sustained high rpm? Didn't think so. Guys, get your heads from whoever you TRUST and can afford. For some people, they just have to have a set of small chamber, big ti valve and spring heads for 10k. Some guys just want a good top end "tune up" for 3-5k. Many engine guys do Viper heads, more then most people realize. Some engine builders have more experience than others with Vipers. There are engine builders out there that may have never touched a Viper head, and I would have no problem with them working a set of heads for me. Kyle is right boys. Do you think Eicke, Nickens, Leonard, Maskin could make a Viper head flow?hhhhhmmmmmm....I think some god, er...a..guy named Lingenfelter has thrown his hat in too.Everyone knows the "Johns" (caldwell and hennessy) stuff works. It's proven. Go with your gut and hope you get what you expect. One last little tid bit....take a look at Bronston's stuff at BPE/Mitech under vendors section...the secret is out!!!dj

------------------
djdunit@victoryvipers.com
'94 RT/10-'97 SST
949.788.6335

This message has been edited by David Jenkins on May 10, 2001 at 12:22


Click Here to See the Profile for David Jenkins   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by David Jenkins   Visit David Jenkins's Homepage!        send a private message to David Jenkins
treynor
Click for full size
Proud VCA Member

From:Redwood City, CA
Registered: Nov 2000

posted 05-10-2001 12:17 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Fred -- no CDI slam at all intended nor (by my read) implied in my original post. By all accounts they do top-notch work, although they're expensive (I was quoted $8,000 for head porting & valves/springs/retainers). The point of my post was twofold:
(a) present empirical data on flow for two different tuners, and
(b) give Hennessey credit where that credit was clearly due.

More generally, as many of you know I've been methodically upgrading my Viper and testing after each round of upgrades to provide some useful data points to the Viper community. I report both the welcome news (like these flow numbers) as well as the unwelcome (a 16HP peak gain on my '01 when headers & catback were added). I trust that, although I may ruffle some feathers with the data I report, on the whole the information I'm providing is a net positive to other board members and will help guide others who are contemplating proceeding down the modification path.

------------------
Cheers, Ben ('98M3'99RX300'00M5'01GP1200R'01RT/10AndNoGarageSpaceLeft!)


Click Here to See the Profile for treynor   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by treynor   Visit treynor's Homepage!        send a private message to treynor
SoCal Rebell
Click for full size
SoCal VCA Member

From:Mission Hills, Ca USA
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-10-2001 12:33 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Keep ruffling those feathers Ben, the info you provide has been very helful to me personally.

------------------
2000 triple black RT/10, BTR Belanger Tri-Y headers, bullet cats, 3" catbacks, 3.54 gear, lightweight flywheel, S&B filters, smooth tubes.

431.4 RWHP 472.4 ft-lbs torque


Click Here to See the Profile for SoCal Rebell   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by SoCal Rebell      Send ICQ message to: 11422     send a private message to SoCal Rebell
Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder
SoCal VCA Member

From:Saratoga,CA
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-10-2001 12:36 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Agree many places can do head work and the result will be unknown. And many tuners do head work and make more HP. But to say "Better than Caldwell" is not correct in my opinion and I do understand that in this case it makes Caldwell the standard company to be measured against. However I do not feel that posting "Better than Caldwell" is correct! Caldwell is not on this board to comment and I will make sure that anyone who is not familiar with Caldwell and the other tuners get the straight story. If you check my posting history, I do not use tuner names with negative post. If the truth be known Caldwell would likely care less about the post. They are in a different league, building endurance race engines.

------------------
Fred Kinder

This message has been edited by Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder on May 10, 2001 at 20:36


Click Here to See the Profile for Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder           send a private message to Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder
Alan M 98 GTS NY

From:upstate NY
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-10-2001 04:12 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Lets see, there is another engine cost also. CDI wants to refresh the GTSR motors after 30 hours of operation. Any tuner have a program like that? I haven't heard one. Better install a low hour one if its a 24 Hr race.

------------------
Alan Modzelewski
98 Red GTS

This message has been edited by Alan M 98 GTS NY on May 10, 2001 at 16:13


Click Here to See the Profile for Alan M 98 GTS NY   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by Alan M 98 GTS NY           send a private message to Alan M 98 GTS NY
Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder
SoCal VCA Member

From:Saratoga,CA
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-10-2001 09:00 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Hi Ben, thanks for your comments. I over reacted to the "Better than Caldwell" topic. There are many options to increase the Vipers performance which is great for the Viper Nation. I also like to share information. I discussed the flow numbers with Caldwell and the answer easy, what do you want, Max. HP little consideration for endurance (like a motor for drag racing), that is taken apart daily or between runs, a sprint motor for qualification and short races or an endurance motor. It is nice to have so many choices that are relatively good and with various cost for something similar. I am not a drag racer or I would join you some wed. at Sears to help hold up the Viper image. That might be a good event for the 1/4 mile guys in the area. If we get a good turn out at the June 22-24 zone event, perhaps we could get them to stick around and show their stuff at the Sears points 1/4 strip. It would be fun to watch the tuners show their stuff.

------------------
Fred Kinder


Click Here to See the Profile for Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder           send a private message to Fred(DrivingSchool)Kinder
AndyF

From:Oregon
Registered: Apr 2001

posted 05-13-2001 09:19 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Unless the heads were flowed on the same bench by the same tech, you probably can't really compare the numbers. Flow benches are like dynos, you can make them do most anything you want. Those numbers are so close I'd say there is no difference between them. Unless of course, those were back to back runs on the same bench under the same conditions.

------------------


Click Here to See the Profile for AndyF   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by AndyF           send a private message to AndyF
Shakedown

From:Daytona Beach, FL U.S.A.
Registered: Mar 2001

posted 05-14-2001 11:38 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


As long as they were flowed at the same test pressure(exp. 28" of water) and the test bore was the same(such as 4.00"), you can compare numbers all day long. How do you think this industry operates. And you want to say there is no difference between them, you obviously missed the low lift #'s.....I think HMS has 'em covered. And yes Fred, in this case, when one number is higher than the other, it is BETTER.

------------------
1998 Yellow Cobra
2001 Yellow Z06
1998 Siver 650 Venom Viper
2001 Secret LS7 White Camaro
1987 Black Turbo V6 Grand National
2001 CL500 MB
1999 Ford F550
1996 Peterbuilt Tow Rig
53' Featherlite Trailer


Click Here to See the Profile for Shakedown   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by Shakedown           send a private message to Shakedown
AndyF

From:Oregon
Registered: Apr 2001

posted 05-15-2001 12:59 AM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Flowing them at the same pressure and the same bore would be a good start, but not the whole answer. The extension (if any) added to the port will play a big role in the flow numbers. And of course, we might be interested in the test conditions. How the bench was calibrated is important as is the test procedure.

And I know exactly how this industry operates. Primarily on BS! Only thing that keeps the aftermarket industry from going under is the fact that most of its customers are too stupid to know they've been ripped off. Why do you think all those kids drive around with 5 inch tips on their exhaust pipes?

------------------


Click Here to See the Profile for AndyF   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by AndyF           send a private message to AndyF
treynor
Click for full size
Proud VCA Member

From:Redwood City, CA
Registered: Nov 2000

posted 05-15-2001 02:04 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


Disagree. The performance improvements I and others have obtained using aftermarket components are quite substantial, and have been repeatedly documented. Part of the purpose of testing and reporting objective results is to allow consumers (in this case other Viper owners) to decide whether the actual performance gains are worth the price of admission.

Flow numbers are interesting because they are suggestive of the degree of performance improvement one can expect from swapping heads. Obviously, the definitive data points will come when these heads are installed and the car is re-dyno'd and re-run at the dragstrip. However, based on the flow numbers obtained, I have every reason to believe I'll see a 12-15% horsepower gain with the Hennessey Power Pak installed. 50-60 extra RWHP would be, if you'll pardon my saying so, "No BS"

------------------
Cheers, Ben ('98M3'99RX300'00M5'01GP1200R'01RT/10AndNoGarageSpaceLeft!)


Click Here to See the Profile for treynor   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by treynor   Visit treynor's Homepage!        send a private message to treynor
John Hennessey / HMS
Click for full size
Texas VCA Member

From:Houston, TX
Registered: Oct 2000

posted 05-15-2001 06:14 PM   

Back to the top IP Logged


FYI, our heads are hand-ported in-house by our machinist, Brad and that's mostly what he does (and does very well I might add) for us during his 40 hours a week. CDI has some great products, including their heads. No need for anyone to get their panties into a twist here.

We are happy to service Ben, Martin and many others with our Venom Power Pack, including our cylinder heads, etc. This is a great way to get your Snake from 440-450 rw hp up to and over 500 rw hp.

BTW, Fred, you should probably get a few more driving schools under your belt before adding anymore power. Have fun,

------------------
John Hennessey
Hennessey Motorsports
"Too Much Horsepower is Never Enough"

Venom 800 Twin Turbo
760 rw hp & 830 rw lb-ft @ 8 psi (4/17/01)
Best 1/4 Mile ET: 10.11 sec.(3/17/01)
Best 1/4 Mile Trap Speed: 140.8 mph (4/22/01)


Click Here to See the Profile for John Hennessey / HMS   Edit/Delete Message    Reply w/Quote   Search for more posts by John Hennessey / HMS           send a private message to John Hennessey / HMS

All times are synchronized with CAAP!  Top of Page

 Return to Performance Modifications   Back To Main Page

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Viper Club of America

Dodge, Viper, RT/10, the Viper logo and likeness are registered trademarks used with permission of the Daimler Chrysler Corporation. © '96-'02 ViperClub.org, IVR Inc., Viper Club of America


Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.45c